Dineo Ranaka Responds to Nandi Madida’s Call for Empathy Towards Black Men

South African radio personality Dineo Ranaka has sparked a heated conversation online after publicly disagreeing with Nandi Madida’s recent comments about extending grace to Black men. Ranaka took to Instagram to share her concerns, responding to Madida’s appearance on L-Tido’s podcast, where the award-winning actress and musician reflected on the historical and systemic barriers facing Black men.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by L-Tido Network (@ltido_network)

During the podcast, Madida spoke candidly about the long shadow of oppression and the lack of structural support available to many Black men trying to better their circumstances. “Our black men have gone through so much, and financially, it’s almost impossible to try [to] empower yourself. Even when you try, the system is against you,” Madida said. She went on to question the reality of economic mobility after centuries of exclusion, asking, “People don’t have support from the government. Your 400 years of being oppressed, where is this money going to come from?”

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Dineo Ranaka (@dineoranaka)

While Madida’s comments were met with empathy by many listeners, Ranaka made it clear that she was deeply unsettled by both the message and the context in which it was delivered. “No, I’m really disturbed by what Nandi said. How she said it and to whom she was saying it. And the climate in which we live, and how what she said will be understood and misconstrued by the very men she’s campaigning empathy for,” Ranaka wrote.

Ranaka explained that her disagreement was not rooted in personal grievance but in what she has observed over time. She stressed that empathy, while important, should not be handed out without accountability. “Now I’m not saying be without empathy. But I’m saying don’t be careless with it. We can’t just willy-nilly feel sorry and not hold accountable,” she said.

According to Ranaka, the issue is not whether Black men deserve compassion, but whether that compassion is matched with responsibility and action. “Slow down on throwing a pity party for black men who aren’t fighting for the economic emancipation of the black nation at the same level of the empathy required,” she stated.

She went further, drawing parallels between public empathy and leadership failures over the years. “Over 30 years, we’ve given empathy to our black leaders in governance. Over 30 years of empathy and hope. And what are the results? The Madlanga Commission. High violent crimes. Unstable economy. High taxes,” she added.

Ranaka also urged deeper scrutiny of behaviour, choices and priorities. “It takes for you to analyse how these men we must have empathy for spend their 24hrs… Analyse the things they say. The things they do. ESPECIALLY the things they do,” she wrote, emphasising intention, movement and long-term vision. She questioned whether some men are truly invested in the future of the Black nation or merely in personal gain, urging analysis on both a micro and macro level.

Anticipating backlash, Ranaka did not shy away from the potential fallout. In the caption of her post, she wrote, “I’m expecting insults for this one … It’s ok though. Black men aren’t what happened to them. They are what they choose to be.”